Accounting control systems: recording variances in
integrated ledgers by Janet Payne
The Fundamentals of Management Accounting (BA2) syllabus requires
you to be able to “prepare a set of integrated accounts, showing
standard cost variances”. This third and last article in the series on
accounting control systems will look at how ledger accounts are
maintained in an integrated standard costing system.
To be able to understand the workings of an integrated standard cost
bookkeeping system, you first need to understand the meaning of
standard cost variances for materials, labour and variable overhead. You
also need to be able to calculate these variances, which feature in BA2
syllabus. Thus more than one syllabus section can be tested in a single
assessment question, which is a key issue that you must appreciate to
be successful in BA2.
Variance accounts
Usually a separate ledger account is kept for each cost variance. Thus there will be an
account for the material price variance, an account for the material usage variance, and so
on.
An adverse variance is debited to the variance account and a favourable variance is credited
to the variance account. This is fairly straightforward but many students experience difficulty
in understanding where to record the ‘other side’ of the double entry for each variance.
Recording the occurrence of the variance
As a general rule, the ‘other side’ of the double entry for each variance is shown in the
account which records where the variance arose. For example:
The material usage variance arises because the quantity of material used during
production is different from standard. The variance is therefore recorded in the work
in progress control account, where all the costs incurred during production are
recorded.
The material price variance arises because the price paid for material is different
from standard. This occurs as materials are purchased and received into stores and
is therefore recorded in the materials control account.
The labour rate variance arises because the hourly rate paid for labour is different
from the standard rate. This occurs as wages are paid and the variance is therefore
recorded in the wages control account.
The labour efficiency and variable production overhead efficiency variances arise
because the number of labour hours used during production are different from
standard. These variances are therefore recorded in the work in progress control
account.
The variable production overhead expenditure variance arises because a different
hourly rate is paid for variable overhead than standard. This occurs as overheads are
paid and the variable overhead expenditure variance is therefore usually recorded in
the production overhead control account.
Example
Last period the quantity of material used was higher than the standard for the actual
output, but the number of labour hours worked was lower than standard.
Extracts from the relevant accounts are shown below. Both differences arose during the
production process and the variances are therefore recorded in the work in progress
control account. The labour and variable overhead efficiency variances are favourable
and are therefore credits in the variance accounts. The adverse material usage variance
is a debit in the variance account.
Work in progress control account
$
$
Labour efficiency variance xx
Material usage variance zz
Var o’head efficiency variance yy
Labour efficiency variance account
$
$
Work in progress control xx
Variable overhead efficiency variance account
$
$
Work in progress control yy
Material usage variance account
$
$
Work in progress control zz
In addition to understanding how to record a standard cost variance, an assessment
question may also require you to calculate the relevant variance or variances.
Example
The standard price of material M is $3 per kg. There are 60kg in stores on 1
st
September.
On 5
th
September 500kg of material M are purchased for $3.50 per kg and 400kg are issued
to production.
An integrated standard cost accounting system will record these materials movements as
follows.
Materials control account Material M
$
$
Inventory b/f (60kg x $3 ) 180
Work in progress (400kg x $3) 1,200
Payables (500kg x $3.50) 1,750
Material price variance 250
Inventory c/f (160kg x $3) 480
1,930
1,930
Material price variance account
$
$
Materials control 250
The adverse material price variance of $250 ($0.50 per kg x 500kg purchased) is recorded
as a debit in the variance account. The corresponding credit entry is in the materials control
account and the closing inventory of 160kg is valued at the standard price of $3 per kg.
The Statement of Profit or Loss (the Income Statement)
At the end of the period, the total of each of the variance accounts is transferred to the
Statement of Profit or Loss.
An adverse variance total will be debited to the Statement of Profit or Loss and a favourable
variance total will be credited. For example, if the material price variance in the example
above is the only price variance to arise during the period, the variance account will look like
this at the end of the period:
Material price variance account
$
$
Materials control 250
Statement of Profit or Loss 250
The variance is adverse and will therefore be a debit in the Statement of Profit or Loss, to be
offset against the standard production cost which will have been transferred from the
finished goods control account.
Summary
For your BA2 computer based assessment you must be able to account for variable
production cost variances in the context of an integrated accounting system.
This article has demonstrated the main entries that you will need to understand. The
questions and answers linked to the article will give you practise in dealing with assessment
style questions on this topic.
Practice Questions
Before attempting these practice questions, read Janet’s article on recording variances in
integrated ledgers.
Question 1
Which one of the following shows the correct entries to record a favourable material price
variance?
A
Debit
Material price variance account
Credit
Materials control account
B
Debit
Materials control account
Credit
Material price variance account
C
Debit
Material price variance account
Credit
Work in progress control account
D
Debit
Work in progress control account
Credit
Material price variance account
Answer 1
The correct answer is B. The variance is favourable therefore it must be a credit in the
variance account. This eliminates options A and C. Option D is incorrect because the price
variance is eliminated at the point of receipt of the materials, i.e. in the materials control
account.
Question 2
Which one of the following shows the correct entries to record an adverse labour rate
variance?
A
Debit
Labour rate variance account
Credit
Wages control account
B
Debit
Wages control account
Credit
Labour rate variance account
C
Debit
Labour rate variance account
Credit
Work in progress control account
D
Debit
Work in progress control account
Credit
Labour rate variance account
Answer 2
The correct answer is A. The variance is adverse therefore it must be a debit in the variance
account. This eliminates options B and D. Option C is incorrect because the rate variance is
eliminated at the point that wages are paid, i.e. in the wages control account.
Question 3
Standard usage of material for one unit of product P is 5kg at $3 per kg. Last period, 4,550
kg of material were purchased at a price of $3.20 per kg and used to produce 900 units of
product P. Which one of the following shows the correct entries to record the material usage
variance?
A
Debit
Material usage variance account
Credit
Work in progress control account
B
Debit
Material usage variance account
Credit
Work in progress control account
C
Debit
Material usage variance account
Credit
Materials control account
D
Debit
Material usage variance account
Credit
Materials control account
Answer 3
The correct answer is B. The variance arises during production thus the entry is made in the
work in progress control account. This eliminates options C and D.
The variance value is ((900 x 5kg standard) 4,550kg actual) x $3 = $150 adverse.
Option A is incorrect because it uses the actual price, rather than the standard price, to
evaluate the variance.
Question 4
The standard variable overhead rate is $0.90 per direct labour hour. During the latest period
the number of labour hours worked was higher than standard for the output achieved. Which
one of the following shows the correct entries to record the variable overhead efficiency
variance?
A
Debit
Work in progress control account
Credit
Variable overhead efficiency variance account
B
Debit
Wages control account
Credit
Variable overhead efficiency variance account
C
Debit
Variable overhead efficiency variance account
Credit
Wages control account
D
Debit
Variable overhead efficiency variance account
Credit
Work in progress control account
Answer 4
The correct answer is D. The variance arises during production thus the entry is made in the
work in progress control account. This eliminates options B and C.
The variable overhead is linked to labour hours, which were higher than standard. Thus the
efficiency variance is adverse and is debited in the variance account and the correct answer
is D.