!
!"#$%&'()*%!%&+(,#-#".&-/(*0& *1234514&36&,178983:9&
,178983:;& <=<=&!%&>>?&
,37@15;& -ABC>?CD?D&
"4EA1F;& '1251BG14&>HI&<=< =&
,178F1F;& /753G14&>JI&<=<=&
&
)K:1L; & !%",I&M/*!"$I&+"N"*I&O(!)O*%PI&K:F&-/$$/*'I&++Q&
&
&
*/N#$&!-,/$".,&15&KLQ&
&
& RQ&
&
-#0P&/S&)/*0."$,&
&
&
-/$$/*'I&+Q&
TU>V&&0W1&-85X&36&)345LK:F&K221KL9&643B&5W1&F1:8KL&GX&5W1&'A214834&-3A45 &
Y-ABG14LK:F& -3A:5X," O’Neil," J.Z& 36& 859& B3583:& 634& 9ABBK4X& [AFEB1:5& 3:&
8BBA:85X& E43A:F9& 8:& K& 9A85& G43AEW5& GX& *3G145& )1LL15814& K:F& W89& \861I& *3G8:&
!7,3:KLFI&GK91F&3 :&8:[A4819&5WK5&)1LL15814&KLL1E1FLX&41718R1F&K6514&6KLL8:E&3:&871&
3A598F1&36&5W1&)345LK:F&)3L871&,12K45B1:5Q&&N17KA91&5W1&2LK]K&\W141&W1&61LL&89&
K:& K22A451:K:71& 53& K& 2AGL87& GA8LF8:E& \85W8:&5W1& B1K:8:E& 36& 5W1& !K8: 1& 0345&
-LK8B9&"75I&>D&!Q*Q'Q&^&_>=DC"Y<Z&Y<=<=ZI&\1&K6684BQ&
#Q&&N"-`M*/($,&
TU<V&&0W1&63LL3\8:E&6K759&K41&A:F892A51FQ&&/:&S1G4AK4X&>aI&<=>aI&)1LL15814&
9L8221F&K:F&61LL&3:&K&2K57W&36&871&K6514&1b858:E&5W1&L3GGX&36&5W1&)345LK:F&)3 L871&
,12K45B1:5& W1KFcAK45149&GA8LF8:EQ&&)1LL15814&61LL&K2243b8BK51LX&98b&53&18EW5&6115&
<&
643B&5W1&F334&36&5W1&GA8LF8:EQ&&0W1&K41K&\W141&W1&61LL&89&K&G487@C2KR1F&2LK]K&5WK5&
1b51:F9& 643B& 5W1& 1:54K:71& 36& 5W1& GA8LF8:E& 53& !8FFL1& '54115& K:F& 53& K& 2K4@8:E&
EK4KE1Q&&0W1&2LK]K&89&2K458KLLX&321:&53&5W1&9@X&KG3R1d&K&234583:&36&5W1&GA8LF8:Ee9&
KAF85348AB&3R14WK:E9&5W1&K41K&\W141&)1LL15814&61LLQ&
TUJV&&0W1&1:5841&K41K&A:F14:1K5W&5W1&2LK]K&89&2K45&36&5W1&)345LK:F&)3L871&
,12K45B1:5& W1KFcAK45149& GA8LF8:EQ& & 0WK5& 2K45& 36& 5W1& GA8LF8:E& 89& A91F& K9& K&
W3LF8:E&21:&K:F&K&2K4@8:E&K41K&634&73BBK:F&95K66& K:F&K:&1R8F1:7 1&517W:878K:&
54A7@I&K:F&85&89&K771991F&5W43AEW&K:&3R14W1KF&F334&5WK5&6K719&!8FFL1&'54115Q&
TUDV& & 0W1& 2LK]K& 89& A91F& GX& 21F19548K:9& 634& K77199& 53& 5W1& ,12K45B1:5&
GA8LF8:EI&K&2K4@8:E&EK4KE1I&K:F&!8FFL1& '54115Q&&,12K45B1:5& 95K66&A91&5W1&2LK]K&53&
2K4@&B35347X7L19&K:F&G87X7L19d&W3\1R14I&9A7W&2K4@8:E&89&: 35&KLL3\1F&8:&5W1&K41K&
36&5W1&2LK]K&\W141&)1LL15814&61LLQ&&)132L1&KL93&A91&5W1&2LK]K&53&1 K5&LA:7W&3A598F1Q &
TUHV&&)W353E4K2W9&36&5W1&2LK]KI&\85W&K& BK4@8:E&8:F87K58:E&\W141&)1LL158 14&
61LLI&K221K4&8:&5W1&41734FI&93B1&36&\W87W&K221K4&G1L3\&K9&S8EA419&>I&<I&K:F&JQ&
J&
Figure"1"
Figure"2"
D&
Figure"3"
TUfV&&!7,3:KLF&K:F&)1LL15814&68L1F&K&73B2LK8:5&KEK8:95&5W1&-85X&8:&<=>_I&
7LK8B8:E& :1EL8E1:71& K:F& L399& 36& 73:93458ABQ& & 0W1& -85X& K991451F& K& :ABG14& 36&
K6684BK58R1&F161:919I&8:7LAF8:E&5WK5&85&\K9&8BBA:1&643B&9A85&G17KA9 1&5W1&7LK8B9&
F8F&:35&6KLL&\85W8:&K:&1b712 583:&53&8BBA:85X&73:5K8:1F&8:&5W1&!K8:1&0345& -LK8B9&
"75Q&&0W1&-85X&93AEW5&9ABBK4X&[AFEB1:5&3:&5WK5& E43A:FI&K:F& !7,3:KLF& K:F&
)1LL15814&322391F&5W1&B3583:I&K4EA8:E&5WK5&85&9W3ALF&G1&F1:81F&K9& K&BK5514&36&
H&
LK\I&34I&KL514:K58R1LXI&5WK5&85&9W3ALF&G1&F1:81F&G17KA91&36&2A423451F&899A19&36&
BK5148KL&6K75&41EK4F8:E&5W1&F198E:I&A91I&K:F&2A42391&36&5W1&2LK]KQ
>
&
TUaV& & /:& $3R1BG 14& <>I& <=>?I& 5W1& 7 3A45& 1:5141F& K:& 34F14& F1:X8:E& 5W1&
-85Xe9& B3583:Q& & g85W3A5& 1LKG34K583:I& 5W1& 7 3A45& 73:7LAF1F& 5WK5& 5W141& \141&
A:8F1:58681F&hBK5148KL&899A19&36&6K75&8:&F892A51&41EK4F8:E&\W15W14&34&:35&5W1&6KLL&
533@& 2LK71& 8:&K:& K 22A451:K:71& 53& K& E3R14:B1:5&GA8LF8:E&\W87W& \3ALF&G1&K:&
1b712583:& 53& 8BBA:85XQi&&0W1&-85X&58B1LX&K221KL1FQ&&See&>D&!Q*Q'Q&^&>_H>&Y<=<=Zd&
!Q*Q&"22Q&)Q&<NY7ZY>ZQ&
##Q&&,#'-(''#/$&
"Q& *1R81\KG8L85X&36&5W1&'ABBK4X&+AFEB1:5&!3583:&
TU_V& & "221KL9& 643B& 5W1& F1:8KL& 36& K& B3583:& 634& 9ABBK4X& [AFEB1:5& K41&
hE1:14KLLX&GK441F&GX&5W1&68:KL&[AFEB1:5&4AL1Qi&&Rod riguez"v."Town"of"Moose"RiverI&
<==a&!%&f_I&U&>fI&?<<&"Q<F&D_DQ""hg1&WKR1&73:98951:5LX&W1LFI&W3\1R14I&5WK5&5W 1&
F1:8KL& 36& K& B3583:& 634& 9ABBK4X& [AFEB1:5& GK91F& 3:& K& 7LK8B& 36& 8BBA:85X& 89&
8BB1F8K51LX&41R81\KGL1&2A49AK:5&53&K:&1b712583:&53&5W1&68:KL&[AFEB1:5&4AL1Qi&&
J.R.M.,"Inc."v."City"of"PortlandI&ff?&"Q<F&>H?I&>f=&Y!1Q&>??H Zd&see"also&Polley"v."
>
&&!7,3:KLF&K:F&)1LL15814&K221K4&53&WKR1&KGK:F3:1F&5W184&K4EAB1:5&5WK5&5W141&89&K&E1:A8:1&F892A51&
36&BK5148KL&6K75&5WK5&2417LA F19&4193LA583:&36&5W1&8BBA:85X&899A1&GA5&:1R145W1L199&73:51:F&5WK5&5W1&
A:F892A51F&6 K759&F3&:35&1:585L1&5W1&-85X&53&9ABBK4X&[AFEB1:5&K9&K& BK5514&36&LK\Q& &See&!Q*Q&"22Q&)Q&
<-YKZY>Z&Yh":&K221LL11&BKXI&\85W3A5&68L8:E&K&74399CK221KLI&K4EA1&5WK5&KL514:K58R1&E43A:F9&9A22345&5W1&
[AFEB1:5&5WK5&89&3:&K221KLQiZQ&
f&
AtwellI& H_>& "Q<F& D>=I& D><&Y!1Q& >??=Z& Y:358:E&5WK5& hG17KA91& 8BBA:85X&89&Q&Q&Q &
8BBA:85X&643B&9A85&4K5W14&5WK:&K&B141&F161:91& 53&L8KG8L85XIi&85& h89&1661758R1LX&L395&
86&K&7K91&89&1443:13A9LX&214B8551F&53&E3&53&548KLi&Y1B2WK989&3B8551FZ&YcA35K583:&
BK4@9& 3B8551FZZQ& & )A49AK:5& 53& 5W89& 1b712583:I& \1& \8LL&41K7W& 5W1& B14859&36& K:&
K221KL&hT1VR1:&\W1:&5W1&548KL&73A45&F178F19&5WK5&5W141&89&K&F892A51&36&BK5148KL&
6K75i&93&L3:E&K9&5W1&2K45819&F3&:35&F892A51&5W1&6K759&BK5148KL&53&5W1&L1EKL&cA19583:&
36&8BBA:85XQ&&RodriguezI&<==a&!%&f_I&UU&>fC>aI&?<<&"Q<F&D_Dd&Paschal"v."City"of"
BangorI&<===&!%&H=I&UU&>&j&:Q>I&>>I&aDa&"Q<F&>>?DQ&
TU?V& & #:& 5W89& 7K91I& KL5W3AEW& 5W1& 73A45& F1:81F& 5W1& - 85Xe9& B3583:& 634&
9ABBK4X& [AFEB1:5& 3:& 5 W1& G K989& 5WK5& 5W141& \141& hBK5148KL& 899A19& 36& 6 K75& 8:&
F892A51&41EK4F8:E&\W15W14&34&:35&5W1&6KLL&533@&2LK71&8:&K:&K22A451:K:71&53&K &
E3R14:B1:5&GA8LF8:E&\W87W&\3ALF&G1&K: &1b712583:&53&8BBA:85XIi&5W1&2K45819&F3&
:35&F892A51&5W1&L37K583:&36&)1LL15814e9&6KLLI&5W1&7WK4K7514895879&36&5W1&2LK]KI&34&5W1&
A919&36&5W1&2LK]KI&K:F&F3&:35&35W14\891&73:51:F&5WK5&5W141&K41&E1:A8:1&F892A519&
36&BK5148KL&6K75Q&&0W1&cA 19583:&36 &\W15W14&5W1&2LK]K&89&K&2AGL87&GA8LF8:E &34 &K:&
K22A451:K:71&53&K&2AGL87&GA8LF8:E&89&5W1416341&K&L1EKL&cA19583:I&:35&K&6K75AKL&3:1Q&&
See"Tolliver"v."Dep’t"of"Transp.I&<==_&!%&_JI&U&>=&:QHI&?D_&"Q<F&><<J&Y1b2LK8:8:E&
5WK5&KL5W3AEW&5W1&899A1&36&8BBA:85X&7K:&G1&h8:5145\8:1F&\85W&5W1&6K759&36&K&7K91Ii&
5W1&KRK8LKG8L85X&36&8BBA:85X&2A49AK:5&53&5W1&!K8:1&0345&-LK8B9&"75&hE1:14KLLX &
a&
5A4:9&3:&5W1&243214&8:5142415K583:&36&5W1&95K5A51I&KG91:5&K&F892A51&36&BK5148KL&
6K75I&K:F&89&5W1416341&K&cA19583:&36&LK\iZQ
<
&&"7734F8:ELXI&\1&41K7W&5W1&B14859&36&
5W1&-85Xe9&K221KLQ&&See"RodriguezI&<==a&!%&f_I&UU&>fC>aI&?<<&"Q<F&D_Dd&PaschalI&
<===&!%&H=I&UU&>&j&:Q>I&>>I&aDa&"Q<F&>>?DQ&
NQ& 0W1&)AGL87&NA8LF8:E&%b712583:&53&#BBA:85X&
TU>=V& & 0W1& -85X& K4EA19& 5WK5& 5W1& A:F892A51F& 6K759& 9W3\& 5WK5& 5W1& 2LK]K&
\W141&)1LL15814&61LL&F319&:35&6KLL&8:53&5W1&2AGL87&GA8LF8:E&1b712583:&53&93R1418E:&
8BBA:85XI&K:FI&5W1416341I&G35W&)1LL15814e9&7L K8B&K:F&!7,3:KLFe9&F148RK58R1&L399&
36&73:93458AB&7LK8B&9W3ALF&G1&F892391F&36&3:&8BBA:85X&E43A:F9Q&&See"Brown"v. "
Crown" Equip." Corp.I&<==_&!%& >_fI& U& <JI&?f=& "Q<F&>>__& YW3LF8:E& h5WK5& L399& 36&
73:93458AB& 7LK8B9& :17199K48LX& K4891& 643B& 5W1& 9 KB1& :1EL8E1:5& K75& K9& 5W1&
A:F14LX8:E& 5345& 7LK8B9& K:F& K41& 5W1416341& 9AG[175& 53& 5W1& 9KB1& 4AL19& K:F&
L8B85K583:9iZQ &
TU>>V&&hg1&41R 81\&K&F1:8KL&36&K&B3583 :&634&9ABBK4X&[AFEB1:5&GK91F&3 :&
K&7LK8B&36&8BBA:85X&634&144349&36&LK\I&R81\8:E&5W1&1R8F1:71&8:&5W1&L8EW5&B395&
6KR34KGL1&53&5W1&:3:B3R8:E&2K45XQi&&RodriguezI&<==a&!%&f_I&U&>?I&?<<&"Q<F&D_DQ&&
<
&&#6&5W141&\141&K&E1:A8:1&F892A51&36&BK5148KL&6K75&5WK5&K661751F&5W1&4193LA583:&36&5W1&L1EKL&cA19583:&
36&\W15W14&5W1&2LK]K&6KLL9&\85W8:&K:&1b712583:&53&5W1&!K8:1&0345&-LK8B9&"75I&\1&\3ALF&G1&A:KGL1& 53&
41R81\& 5W1& F1:8KL& 36& 5W1& -85Xe9& B3583:& 634& 9ABBK4X& [AFEB1:5Q& & See" Wilcox" v." City" of" PortlandI&
<==?&!%&HJI& U& >DI& ?a=& "Q<F& <?H& Yh,1:8KL& 36& K& B3583:& 634& 9ABBK4X& [AFEB1:5& GK91F& 3:& 5W1&
F1514B8:K583:&5WK5&5W1&8BBA:85X&899A19&7K::35&G1&4193LR1F&A:58L&6K75C68:F8:E&377A49&89 &:35&K&4AL8:E&
9AG[175&53&K:&8:514L37A534X&K221KL&G16341&5W1&548KL&73A45&7K:&BK@1&5W1&:17199K4X&6K75C68:F8:E9QiZQ&
_&
"G91:5& K& F892A51& 36& BK5148KL& 6K75I& \W15W14& 34& :35& K& E3R14:B1:5KL& 1:585X& 89&
1:585L1F&53&8BBA:85X&89&K&cA19583:&36&LK\&5WK5&\1&41R81\&F1&:3R3Q& &Se e"Tollive rI&
<==_&!%&_JI&UU&>=&:QHI&>>I&?D_&"Q<F&><<JQ&
TU><V&&M3R14:B1:5KL&8BBA:85X&89&73F8681F&8:&5W1&!K8:1&0345&-LK8B9&"75 &
Y!0-"ZI&>D&!Q*Q'Q&^^&_>=>C_>>_&Y<=<=ZQ&&0W1&! 0-"&243R8F19&K9&K&E1:14KL&4AL 1&
5WK5&hKLL&E3R14:B1:5KL&1:585819&9WKLL&G1&8 BBA:1&643B&9 A85&3:&K:X&K:F&KLL&5345&
7LK8B9&911@8:E&4173R14X&36&FKBKE19Qi&&Id.&^&_>=JY>ZQ&&0W89&8BBA:85XI&W3\1R14I&
89&L8B851F&GX&91R14KL&1b712583:9I&8:7LAF8:E&5W1&2AGL87&GA8LF8:E&1b712583:I&\W87W&
95K519&5WK5& h TKV&E3R14:B 1:5KL&1:585X&89&L8KGL1&634&859&:1EL8E1:5&K759&34&3B89983 :9&
8:& 5W1& 73:954A7583:I& 3214K583:& 34& BK8:51:K:71& 36& K:X& 2AGL87& GA8LF8:E& 34& 5W1&
K22A451:K:719& 53& K:X& 2AGL87& GA8LF8:EQi& & Id.& ^& _>=DC"Y<ZQ& & %b712583:9& 53&
8BBA:85XI&9A7W&K9&5W1&2AGL87&GA8LF8:E&1b712583:I&hK41&954875LX&73:954A1F&93&K9&53&
KFW141& 53& 8BBA:85X& K9& 5W1& E1:14KL& 4AL1Qi& & See" Searle" v." Town" of" Bucksport I&
<=>=&!%&_?I&U&?I&J&"QJF&J?=Q&
TU>JV& & "9& K:& 8:858KL& BK5514I& 5W141& K221K49& 53& G1& :3& F892A51& 5WK5& 5W1&
,12K45B1:5&GA8LF8:EkG18:E&K771998GL1&53&5W1&2AGL87I&3\:1F&GX &5W1&-85XI&K:F&
914R8:E&K&2AGL87&6A:7583:k89&K&2AGL87&GA8LF8:E&\85W8:&5W1&B1K:8:E&36&5W1&!0-"Q&&
See"RodriguezI&<==a&!%&f_I&U&J<I&?<<&"Q<F&D_D&Yh"&l2AGL87&GA8LF8:Ee&89&K&GA8LF8:E&
5WK5& 89& K771998GL1& 53& 5W1& 2AGL87d& 192178KLLX& 3:1& 3\:1F& GX& 5W1& E3R14:B1:5Qi&
?&
YKL514K583:9&3B8551FZ&YcA35K583:&BK4@9&3B8551FZZQ&&"FF8583:KLLXI&!7,3:KLF&K:F&
)1LL15814& F3& :35& 73 :51:F& 5WK5& 5W1& 2LK]K& 89& 8591L6& K& 2AGL87& GA8LF8:EQ& & 'A7W& K:&
K4EAB1:5&\3ALF&G1&A:KRK8L8:E&E8R1:&5WK5&5W1&2LK]KI&\W87W&89&3A5F3349&K:F&3:LX&
2K458KLLX& 1:7L391FI& LK7@9& 5W1& 4AF8B1:5K4X& 7WK4K7514895879& 36& K& GA8LF8:EQ&&
See"Searle,"<=>=&!%&_?I&U&>=I&J&"QJF&J?=&Y4173E:8]8:E&5WK5&hF168:8583:9&36&5W1&
514B&GA8LF8:E&8:F87K51&K:&1F86871&1 :7L391F&GX&\KLL9&K:F&73R141F&GX&K&4336iZd&Reid"
v.&Town"of"Mount"VernonI&<==a&!%&><HI&U&<<I&?J<&"Q<F&HJ?&Y:358:E&5WK5&K:&321:&
K41K&54K:9614&95K583:&73ALF&:35&G1&73:98F141F&K&GA8LF8:EZd&Adriance"v."Town"of"
StandishI& f_a& "Q<F& <J_I& <D=& Y!1Q& >??fZ& YW3LF8:E& 5WK5& K& h214BK:1:5I& fully"
enclosedi&54K:9614&95K583:&\K9&K&2AGL87&GA8LF8:E &Y1B2WK989&KFF1FZZQ&
TU>DV&&*K5W14I&!7,3:KLF&K:F&)1LL15814&73:51:F&5 WK5&5W1&2LK]K&89&part&36&
5W1& ,12K45B1:5& GA8LF8:EI& 9A7W& 5WK5& 53E15W14& 5W1X& BK@1& A2& K& 98:EL1& 2AGL87&
GA8LF8:EI&34I&KL514:K58R1LXI&5WK5&5W1&2LK]K&89&K:&K22A451:K:71&53&5W1&GA8LF8:EQ&&/A4&
7K91LK\&9AEE1959&5WK5&\W15W14&5W1&2LK]K&89&K:&1b514:KL&2K45&36&5W1&GA8LF8:E&34&
K:& K22A451:K:71& 53& 5W1& GA8LF8:E& 89& K& F8958:7583:& \85W3A5& K& F866141:71Q&&
See"RodriguezI&<==a&!%&f_I&U&<_&:QJI&?<<&"Q<F&D_D&YF19748G8:E&K :&1 b514:KL&915&
36&95K849&L1KF8:E&8:53&K&2AGL87&GA8LF8:E&K9&2K45& 36& 5W1&GA8LF8:E& K:F& KL93&K9&K:&
K22A451:K:71ZQ&
>=&
TU>HV& & #:&K7734FK:71&\85W&917583:&_> =DCY"ZY<ZI& hK:&K22A451:K:71& 89&K:&
3G[175& 34&5W8:E&5 WK5& G1L3:E9&34&89&K55K7W1F&53& K& 2AGL87&GA8LF8:EI&K:F&F319&:35&
8:7LAF1&21493:KL&2432145X&BK8:5K8:1F&3A598F1&5W1&GA8LF8:EQi&&Sanford"v."Town"of"
ShapleighI&<==D&!%&aJI&U&>>I&_H=&"Q<F&J<HQ&&#:&F1514B8:8:E&\W15W14&93B15W8:E &
hG1L3:E9i&53&K&GA8LF8:EI&W3\1R14I&\1&WKR1&41[1751 F&K&6A:7583:CGK91F&K2243K7W&
8:& 6KR34& 36& A98:E& 5W1& h\1LLC195KGL89W1F& F168:8583:& 36& K& 68b5A41& 53& F1514B8:1&
\W15W14& K:& 3G[175& T89V& K:& K22A451:K:71Qi& & SearleI& <=>=& !%& _?I& UU& >JC>DI&
J&"QJF&J?=Q& & 0WA9I& 53& G1& K:& K22A451:K:71I& 5W1& 3G[175& 8:& cA19583:& BA95& G1& K&
68b5A41&4K5W 14&5WK:&21493:KL&2432145XQ&&Id.&U&>DQ&&"&68b5A41&89&93B15W8:E&5WK5&89&
Y>Z&2WX987KLLX&K::1b1F&53&5W1&41KL5XI&Y<Z&KFK251F&53&5W1&41KL5XI&K:F&YJZ&8:51:F1F&
53&G1&8441B3RKGL1&643B&5W1&41KL5XQ&&Id.&UU&>HC<JQ&&# :&73:54K95I&21493:KL&2432145X&
89& K:X& hB3RKGL1& 34& 8:5K:E8GL1& 5W8:E& 5WK5& 89& 9AG[175& 53& 3\:149W82& K:F& :35&
7LK998681F&K9&41KL&2432145XQi&&Id.& U&>H&YcA35K583:&BK4@9&3B8551FZQ&
TU>fV&&0W1&2LK]K&K5&899A1&8:&5W89&7K91&6KLL9&9cAK41LX&\85W8:&5W1&F 168:8583:&
36&K&68b5A41&634&91R14KL&41K93:9Q&&S8495I&5W1&2LK]K&89&K ::1b1F&5 3 &5W1&,12K45B1:5&
GA8LF8:E&G17KA91&85&914R19&K9&5W1&4336&53&5W1&234583:&36&5W1&GA8LF8:E&A:F14:1K5W&
85&K:F&7K::35&G1&6411LX&B3R1F&34&41L37K51FQ&&See"id.&UU&>aC>_Q&&'173:FI&5W1&2LK]K&
89&KFK251F&53&5W1&A:8cA1&:11F9&36&5W1&,12K45B1:5&GA8LF8:E&8:&5WK5&85&89&:17199K4X&
634&5W1&243214&6A:7583:&36&5W1&GA8LF8:EkK9&!7,3:KLF&K:F&) 1LL15814&238:5&3A5I&
>>&
5W1& GA8LF8:Ee9&L3GGX&\3ALF&G1&\W3LLX&8:K771998GL1&\85W3A5&5W1& 2LK]KQ& & See" id.&
UU&>?C<=Q& & 0W84FI& 5W1& K::1bK583:& K:F& 1991:58KL& :K5A41& 36& 5W1& 2LK]K& 53& 5W1&
6A:7583:8:E&36&5W1&,12K45B1:5&GA8LF8:E&9W3\&5WK5&5W1&-85X&WKF&5W 1&h41cA89851&
8:51:5&53&BK@1i&5W1&2LK]K&hK:&8441B3RKGL1&2K45i&36&5W1&,12K45B1:5&GA8LF8:EQ&&Id.&
UU&<>C<<Q&&"7734F8:ELXI&5W1&2LK]K&6KLL9&\85W8:&5W1&F168:8583:&36&K:&K22A451:K:71 &
634& 5W1& 2A423919& 36& >D& !Q*Q'Q& ^& _>=DC"Y<ZQ& & Compare& SearleI& <=>=& !%& _?I&
UU&>aC<JI& J&"QJF&J?=&YW3LF8:E&5WK5&1K98LXCF89K991BGL1FI&E1:1487&GL1K7W149&5WK5&
\141&:35&K::1b1F&53 &5W1&LK:F&\141&21493:KL&2432145XI&:35&K22A451:K:719&53&K&
2AGL87&W8EW&97W33LZI&and&SanfordI&<==D&!%&aJI&U&><I&_H=&"Q<F&J<H&YW3LF8 :E&5WK5&
K& 641195K:F8:E& 54K9W& G8 :& 3A598F1& 36& K& \K951& 6K78L85X& GA8LF8:E& \K9& 21493:K L&
2432145XI& :35& K:& K22A451:K:71ZI& with& RodriguezI& <==a& !%& f_I& U& <_& :QJI&
?<<&"Q<F&D_D& Y:358:E& 5WK5& 1b514:KL& 95K849 & L1KF8:E& 8:53 & K& 2AGL87& GA8LF8:E& 6 KLL&
\85W8:& 5W1& F168:8583:& 36& K:& K2 2A451:K:71ZI& and" Donovan" v." City" of" PortlandI&
<==D&!%&a=I&U&>HI&_H=&"Q<F&J>?&YF19748G8:E&h95K849i&K9&hK22A451:K:7 19iZQ&
TU>aV&&0W1&-85X&F319&:35&R8E343A9LX&K4EA1&5WK5&5W1&2LK]K&6K8L9&53&B115&5W89&
5W411C2K45&5195Q&&#:951KFI&85&73:51:F9& 5WK5&5W1& 2LK]K&7K::35&G1& K :&K22A451:K:71&
G17KA91& 85&89&1991:58KLLX& A91F&K9&K&2 K4@8:E& K41K&K :Fm34&98 F1\KL@Q&&See&>D&!Q*Q'Q&
^&_>=DC"YDZ&Yh"&E3R14:B1:5KL&1:585X&89&:35&L8KGL1&634&K:X&F16175I& LK7@&36&412K84 &
34& LK7@& 36& 9A668781:5& 4K8L8:E& 8:& K:X& Q& Q& Q& 98F1\KL@I& 2K4 @8:E& K41KI& Q& Q& Q& 34& 8:& K:X&
><&
K22A451:K:71&5W14153QiZd&see"also"Kitchen"v."City "of"CalaisI&fff&"Q<F&aaI&a_Ca?&
Y!1Q& >??HZ& Yh"& 2K4@8:E& K41K& 73:9585A519& :185W14& K& 2AGL87& GA8LF8:E& :34& K:&
K22A451:K:71&53&K&2AGL87&GA8LF8:EQ&&"&73:54K4X&8:5142415K583:&\3ALF&BK@1&5W1&
243R8983:9&36&917583:9&_>=DC"Y<Z&K:F&YDZ&41FA:FK:5QiZQ&
TU>_V& & 0W1& !0-"& F319& :35& F168:1& 5W1& 514B9& h2K4@8:E& K41Ki& K:F&
h98F1\KL@Ii&see&>D&!Q*Q' Q&^^&_>=>C_>>_I&K:F&\1&WKR1&:1R14&1b24199LX&F168:1F&
5W1BQ&&h"9&K &E1:14 KL&4AL1I&\34F9&K:F&2W4K919&5WK5&K41&:35&1b24199LX&F168:1F&8:&K&
95K5A51&BA95&G1&E8R1:&5 W184&2LK8:&K:F &:K5A4KL&B1K:8:EIi&A:L199&F38:E&93&\3ALF&
419AL5& 8:&hKG9A4FI& 8LL3E87KLI&34&8:73:98951:5&419AL59Qi&&Sear leI&<=>=&!%&_?I&U&_I&
J&"QJF&J?=&YcA35K583:&BK4@9&3B8551FZQ&
TU>?V&&"L5W3AEW&5W141&89&:3&F892A51&5WK5&,12K45B1:5&95K66&A91&2K45&36&5W1&
2LK]K&53&2K4@&B35347X7L19&K:F&G87X7L19I&5W1&-85X&73:71F1F&5WK5&9A7W&2K4@8:E&89&
:35&214B8551F&3:&5W1&2K45&36&5W1&2LK]K&\W141&)1LL15814&61LLQ&&0WA9I&5W1&K41K&36&5W1&
2LK]K&\W141&)1LL15814&61LL&F319&:35&685&\85W8:&5W1&h2LK8:&K:F&:K5A4KL&B1K:8:Ei&36&
5W1&2W4K91&h2K4@8:E& K41KQi&&Id.d&cf."KitchenI&fff&"Q<F&K5&a_Ca?&YW3LF8:E&5WK5&K&
hGLK7@53221F&K41K&\W141&R1W87L19&K4 1&2 K4@1Fi&\85W&7A4G8:E&h53&@112&R1W87L19&
643B& 2K4@ 8:E& 533& 7L391& 53i& K& 2AGL87& GA8LF8:E& \K9& K& 2K4@8:E& K41K& \85W8:& 5W1&
B1K:8:E&36&917583:&_>=DC"YDZ&4K5W14&5WK:&K :&K22A451:K:71ZQ&&!3413R14I&1R1:&86&
5W1& 1 :5841& 2LK]Kk\W87W& 89& 2WX987KLLX& 2K45& 36 & 5W1& ,12K45B1:5& GA8LF8:E& K:F&
>J&
914R19& 91R14KL& F866141:5& 2A423919kF8F& 685& \85W8:& 5W1& 2LK8:& B 1K:8:E& 36& 5W1&
2W4K91&h2K4@8:E&K41KIi&53&W3LF&5WK5&K&E3R14:B1:5&1:585X&7K:&F161K5&5W1&2AGL87&
GA8LF8:E&1 b712583:&5 3&8BBA:85X&GX&98B2LX&KLL3\8:E&95K66&53&2K4@&B35347X7L19&34&
G87X7L19&3:&\WK5&\3ALF&35W14\891&G1&K:&K22A451:K:7 1&\3ALF&G 1&K :&KG9A4F&3 4&
8LL3E87KL& 419AL5Q& & Cf." Blue"Yonder,"LLC" v."State"Tax"AssessorI&<=>>& !%&D?I&U&>?I&
>a&"QJF& ffa& YF17L8:8:E& 53& KF325& K:& hKG9A4Fi& 8:5142415K583:& 36&K&95K5A51& 5WK5&
h\3ALF&214B85&KR38FK:71&36&TKV&A91&5Kb&98B2LX&GX&54K:923458:E&2432145X&3A598F1&
36&!K8:1&3:71&\85W8:&5\1L R1&B3:5W9&K6514&859&3A5C36C95K51&2A47WK91iZQ&
TU<=V& & '8B8LK4LXI& 5W1& 2LK]K& F319& :35& 685& \85W8:& 5W1& 2LK8:& K:F& :K5A4KL&
B1K:8:E& 36& 5W1& \34F& h98F1\KL@Qi&&See& SidewalkI& 0W1& "B1487K:& O1485KE1&
,87583:K4X&36&5W1&%:EL89W&.K:EAKE1&YH5W&1FQ&<=>fZ&YF168:8:E& h98F1\KL@i&53&B1K:&
hTKV&2KR1F&\ KL@\KX&along"the"side"of"a"streeti&Y1B2WK989&KFF1FZZd&SidewalkI&$1\&
/b634F& " B1487K:& ,87583:K4X& YJF& 1FQ& <= >=Z& YF168:8:E& h98F1\KL@i& 53& B1K:& hK&
2KR1F&2K5W&634&21F19548K:9&at"the"side"of"a" roadi&Y1B2WK9 89&KFF1FZZd&SidewalkI&
g1G9514e9&0W84F&$1\&#:514:K583:KL&,87583:K4X&Y<==<Z&YF168:8:E&h98F 1\KL@i&53&
B1K:&hK&\KL@&634&6335&2K991:E149&usu[ally]"at"the" side" of" a" street"or"roadway;&K&
6335&2KR1B1:5i&Y1B2WK989&KFF1FZZd&cf."DonovanI&<==D&!%&a=I&UU&DI&?I&><I&>HI&
_H=&"Q<F&J>?& Y9AEE1958:E& 5WK5& K:& K41K& L1KF8:E& 643B& K& 2K4@8:E& L35& 53\K4F& K&
2AGL87&97W33L&\K9&K&98F1\KL@ZQ&
>D&
TU<>V& & S8:KLLXI& 5W1& -85X& 73:51:F9& 5WK5& 1R1:& 86& 5W1& 2L K]K& 89& 2K45& 36& 5W1&
,12K45B1:5&GA8LF8:EI&!7,3:KLFe9&K:F&)1LL15814e9&7LK8B9&F3&:35&951B&643B&5W1&
-85Xe9&:1EL8E1:5&BK8:51:K:71&34&3 214K583:&36& 5W1&GA 8LF8:EI&GA5&4K5W14&5W 1&-85Xe9&
h6K8LA41&53&541K5 &871&3:&K&\KL@\ KXi&K:FI&5W1416341I&5W184&7LK8B9&F3&:35&548EE14&K:&
1b712583:& 53& 8BBA:85XQ& & SeeI" e.g.I& ABT" &" A" Co." v." StateI& fDD& "Q<F& Df =I& Df= &
Y!1Q&>??DZ&YW3LF8:E&5WK5&5W1&2AGL87&GA8LF8:E&1b712583:&\K9&8:K22L87KGL1&\W141&
7LK8B9& \141& GK91F& 3:& 5W1& '5K51e9& 9A21 4R8983:& 36& 24893:149& 4K5W14& 5WK:& 5W1&
h3214K583:&34&BK8:51:K:71i&36&K&734417583:KL& 6K78L85 XZQ&&- 3:54K4 X&53&5W1&-85Xe9&
K4EAB1:5I& 5W1& -85Xe9& 6K8LA41& 53& 541K5& 5W1& 87X& 73:F8583:9& 36& 5W1& 2LK]K& 73ALF& G1&
73:98F141F&K&h:1EL8E1:5&K75TV&34&3B89983:TVi&8:&5W1&hBK8:51:K:71i&36&5W1&2LK ]KQ
J
&&
>D&!Q*Q'Q&^&_>=DC"Y<Zd&see"MaintenanceI&NLK7@e9&.K\&,87583:K4X&Y>>5W&1FQ&<=>?Z &
YF168:8:E&hBK8:51:K:71i&53&B1K:&hT5VW1&7K41&K:F&\34@&2A5&8:53&K&2432145X&53&
@112& 85& 3214K58:E& K:F& 243FA758R1d& E1:14KL& 412K84& K:F& A2@112 iZd& Isaacson" v."
Husson" Coll.I& <?a& "Q<F& ?_I& >=D& Y!1Q& >?a<Z& YhT0VW1& F161:FK:5& \K9& :35&
9AG95K:58KLLX&8B21F1F&8:&859&maintenance&36&5W1&2K5W\KX9&K:F&K41K&\KX9&6411&
K:F&7L1K4&36&9:3\Qi&Y1B2WK989&KFF1FZZd&Denman"v."Peoples"Heritage"Bank," Inc.I&
J
&&.8@1&5W1&514B9& h2K4@8:E&K41Ki&K:F& h98F 1\KL@Ii&5W1&!0-"&F319&:35&F168:1&hBK8:51:K:71Ii&see&
>D&!Q*Q'Q&^^&_>=>C_>>_&Y<=<=ZI&K:F&\1&WKR1&:1R14& 1b24199LX&F168:1F & 85Q&& "7734F8:ELXI&\1&BA95&E8R1&
85&859&h2LK8:&K:F&:K5A4KL&B1K:8:EQi&&Searle"v."Town"of"BucksportI&<=>=&!%&_?I&U&_I&J&"QJF&J?=&YcA35K583:&
BK4@9&3B8551FZQ&
>H&
>??_&!%&><I&UU&>C<I&a=D&"Q<F&D>>&YF19748G8:E&h9:3\&K:F&871&41B3RKLi&K9&2K45&
36&K&hmaintenance&73:54K75i&Y1B2WK989&KFF1FZZQ&
TU<<V&&#:&9ABBK4XI&KL5W3AEW&5W1&73A45&1441F&\W1:&85&63A:F&5WK5&5W141&\K9&
K&E1:A8:1&F892A51&36&BK5148KL&6K75&5WK5&2417LAF1F&4193LA583:&36&5W1&cA19583:&36&
8BBA:85XI& 5W1& A:F892A51F& 6K759& 9W3\& 5WK5& 5W1& 2LK]K& 6KLL9& \85W8:& 5W1& 2AGL87&
GA8LF8:E&1b712583:&53&E3R14:B1:5KL&8BBA:85X&K:F&5WK5&5W1&-85X&89&5W1416 341&:35 &
8BBA:1& 643B& !7,3:KLFe9& K:F& )1LL15814e9& 7LK8B9Q& & "7734F8:ELXI& \1& K6684B& 5W1&
F1:8KL&36&5W1&-85Xe9&B3583:&634&9ABBK4X&[AFEB1:5&3:&5WK5&KL514:K58R1&GK989Q&&See"
Sear s," Roebuck" &" Co." v ." State" Tax" AssessorI& <=><& !%& >>=I& U& >JI& H<& "QJF& ?D>&
Y:358:E& 5WK5& \1& BKX& K6684B& K& [AFEB1:5& 3:& E43A:F9& F866141:5& 643B& 5W1& 548KL&
73A45e9&41K93:8:EZd&Jorgensen"v."Dep’t"of"Transp.I&<==?&!%&D<I&U&<>I&?f?&"Q<F&?><&
YF17L8:8:E&53&hF895A4G&5W1&548KL&73A45e9&F1:8KL&36&K&9ABBK4X&[AFEB1:5&8:&6KR34&36&
5W1& , 12K45B1:5&GK91F& 3:&F89741583:K4X& 6 A:7583:&8BBA:85Xi& K6514& 73:7LAF8:E&
5WK5&5W1&,12K45B1:5&\K9&:35&1:585L1F&53&9A7W&8BBA:85XZQ &
0W1&1:54X&89;&
+AFEB1:5&K6684B1FQ&
&
& & & & & &
>f&
&
+3W:&+Q&gKLLI&###I&%9cQ&Y34KLLXZI&!3:KEWK:&.1KWXI&..)I&)345LK:FI&634&K221LLK:5&-85X&
36&)345LK:F&
&
M14K4F& )Q& -3:L1XI& +4QI& %9cQI& K:F& `1::15W& O3R14BKL1I& %9cQ& Y34KLLXZI& -L3A5814I&
-3:L1X& j& ,A66155I& )Q"QI& )345LK:FI& 634& K221LL119& *3G8:& !7,3:KLF& K:F& *3G145&
)1LL15814&
&
&
-ABG14LK:F&-3A:5X&'A214834&-3A45&F37@15&:ABG14&-nC<=>_CJff&
S/*&-.%*`&*%S%*%$-%&/$.P&